Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/steelema/public_html/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/steelema/public_html/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_DIR already defined in /home/steelema/public_html/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Constant FS_CHMOD_FILE already defined in /home/steelema/public_html/wp-config.php on line 101

Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/steelema/public_html/wp-config.php:101) in /home/steelema/public_html/wp-includes/feed-rss2-comments.php on line 8
Comments on: To Create, To Design https://steelemaley.io/2011/03/21/to-create-to-design/ Sun, 27 Mar 2011 09:38:01 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=7.1.5 By: Thomas Steele-Maley https://steelemaley.io/2011/03/21/to-create-to-design/#comment-70 Sun, 27 Mar 2011 09:38:01 +0000 http://blog.steelemaley.io/2011/03/21/to-create-to-design/#comment-70 Howard, sorry it took so long to respond. Your points at "their analysis is true, but where do u go next." are my focus. I am interested in helping networks flow and in co-designing a learning ecology that can serve as a catalyst for more nodes in network. The process of de-schooling is an important one. If we do not read think and deliberate on critical education, I feel we are all stuck in an education without praxis. In my estimation all design starts with theory and social imagination….These are social constructs and "political" at times. Apple and Illich (who I would suggest…..) are both theoretician and practitioner. How Network Learning, connectivism, critical praxis and design can inspire, uplift, and liberate human imagination is of much interest to a growing network of learners. I would like to see, find and connect to more thinking this way…. CC: CCK11

]]>
By: Howard https://steelemaley.io/2011/03/21/to-create-to-design/#comment-69 Tue, 22 Mar 2011 16:49:55 +0000 http://blog.steelemaley.io/2011/03/21/to-create-to-design/#comment-69 Hey Thomas;
I guess my take on ideas that grow our of critical pedagogy (like many other Marxist based schools) is that their analysis is true, but where do u go next. Organizing and revolution with a Marxist bent; I just haven't seen a good example where resistance has worked toward a good outcome in economic or political circumstances. Now I believe Schumpterian creative distruction is rampant and many capitalist strongholds are falling without work resistance. Assembly line models of control aren't serving anyone's purpose anymore and change is in the air. New efforts of control will be attempted and political work is needed. Here is one example: http://chronicle.com/article/Can-Tim-Wu-Save-the-Internet-/126756/ I just want to see that in political contexts like what is happening in Egypt, not through subversive educational and Marxist contexts.
Institutional change is needed in education to serve the students and society. I'm in favor of focusing on people like Dewey and Vygotsky, who focused primarily on education not politics, which I see as the primary focus of critical pedagogy. Vygotsky's life goal was to create a Marxist psychology for education, but his work was banned because it focused on serving the needs of individual students in their context. It didn't fit Stalinist politics (Seems he dared to reference western authors like Piaget).
I do respect your views and I'm welcome to any insights that might help me to return from my abandonment of critical pedagogy. Note – most of my views of critical pedagogy are based on Henry Giroux, Peter McLaren and Paulo Freire. I'm less versed on Apple's work

]]>
By: Thomas Steele-Maley https://steelemaley.io/2011/03/21/to-create-to-design/#comment-68 Tue, 22 Mar 2011 13:55:02 +0000 http://blog.steelemaley.io/2011/03/21/to-create-to-design/#comment-68 Thank you for the response, Howard. Your link to Wertsch is instructive. I will dig into Mind in Action as I have only given it a glance. As for standardization, power and politics I have seen as a teacher the damage curriculum and assessment can do. The nexus between curriculum/assessment and praxis seen in all but the most progressive schools is political in my estimation. Michael Apple (professor and k-12 teacher) summed this up well in Ideology and Curriculum. New York: Routledge, 1990 and Education and Power. New York: Routledge, 1995 along with Ivan Illich Deschooling Society (1970), Bowles and Gintis Schooling in Capitalist America: Educational Reform and the Contradictions of Economic Life. New York: Basic, 1976. I do not see education as a diode but a network of emerging ideas, abilities, failures, and connection–to people, places, and more. My students teach me as much as I teach them, and the community, and a network of experiences teach us all constantly. The barrier to this learning in my experience has always been with the structure of the school which are well ingrained in a politic of stasis and lack of flow. Dewey, Vygotsky, Papert et al. taken, our ability to see beyond structures and the standardization of movements, times, and spaces in learning are not being widely addressed or adopted.

]]>
By: Howard https://steelemaley.io/2011/03/21/to-create-to-design/#comment-67 Tue, 22 Mar 2011 10:18:49 +0000 http://blog.steelemaley.io/2011/03/21/to-create-to-design/#comment-67 Thomas; You bring up many issues, but I'll speak to 3 where I've had some experience and thoughtfulness. Please don't take this as an attempt to rain on your parade. I too would like to seek new ecologies and better understand the ones I see in formation.
1. I've always taken issue with critical educators and reconstructionists in general when it comes to politics. I'm a great supported of education's role in supporting political reform, but I've found it personally frustrating as a teacher when education attempts to lead or inspire political reform.
2. There is very little standardization in educational practice. It is found in control structures like curriculums and assessments and I do believe there it is there to seek control in an obsessive way. There are places where standardized practice could help each teacher not have to continually re-invent the wheel in activities where standardization makes sense. I believe every educational activity could be placed somewhere on a continuum with standardization on one side and individualization on the other. I consider standardization a tool that is only appropriate for some circumstances.
3. Regarding the quote from Dewey; I believe that content is not fully understood until it is embedded in activity and then it takes on the character of that activity. That is, the knowledge you memorized in preparation for recall on a test is not the same knowledge you'll need to do things in real life. It will take substantial contextual adaptation, or internalization as appropriation as James V. Wertsch puts it in "Mind in Action. (Another anthropologist / educator) I think Vygotsky understood this better than Dewey. The task for us is to update Vygotsky. He lived in a world that was comfortable thinking about learning processes in a teacher / student diode, where today we're more inclined to see learning as a networked and ever evolving process.

]]>